Wednesday, March 30, 2005

Response To A Sneering Progressive

Mail this out [CLICK RIGHT HERE] or mail the hyperlink to all your liberal and progressive friends while there's still time. (Can anyone get it onto the Kos or Usenet?) You may also want to include the link that precedes and prompts the tirade so they know what it's about. :)

Here's how it started: In response to the following article, Imagine Terri Were a Toaster ..., I had posted the following message:

Like all absurd arguments, it's based on an incorrect premise: that Terri Schiavo is a toaster that sentimental right-to-lifers are humanizing for their own delusional ends.

Perhaps I'd enjoy the wry humor in it on a different day, but you have to realize... [MORE]

It got the following reply:

Liberals for Terri? Your argument is absurd too.

What the author fails to realize is that if Terri has a soul, which is what most people believe, regardless if you're on Michael Shiavo's side or her parent's side - then there is something still there in the person's body whose wishes Michael wants to respect.

On the other hand - your argument is just ridiculous. This case has been in courts for so long, with experts declaring that she is a vegetable and all of her "reactions", movements, etc. are simply reflexes. This is science, not religion - and believe it or not, in science there are often things underneath what you can see just by using your senses. So it's great that you can see her react to certain stimuli and make noises like "AAAH WAAAAH" but that doesn't mean anything.


I sent this in reply. It's the link at the top of the article. It's basically a point-by-point refutation of the usual positions and a rant on the Liberals For Terri position in a nutshell.

25 Comments:

Blogger Susan said...

Too bad you don't post on Democratic Underground, IF the moderators would allow you to do so.

It's a hole over there regarding Schiavo, with few people with any kind of sense. They've swallowed the MS claims hook, line, and sinker, mostly because they see taking on "his" side as a way to defeat the radical right.

Never mind justice or truth.

7:37 AM  
Anonymous Julie P. said...

RD, all I can say is you are awesome. I have everyone I know reading liberalsforterri, and I am going to send them that link, too. Everyone needs to know...

2:19 PM  
Blogger RD said...

Thanks. Have sent a request for an e-mail account - we'll see how long it takes ("I will ponder it for an eternity... jalan").

3:33 PM  
Blogger RD said...

To the DU, that is. And keep sending 'em - it ain't quite over yet. The last great hope - the one that's really already passed the point of no return - are the wheels of justice (not the blindfold of justice, evidently).

3:35 PM  
Blogger Jill said...

RD -

Excellent work. Love the term 'Sneering Progressives'. Maybe you ought to do this for a living - defending people like Terri. I really think we're going to need it. I have just about given up hope on these 'sneering progressives' - they seem to be in PDS - Persistant Denial State. No matter how many times you lay the facts out before them - facts as plain as day - they seem to be morally blind. I've sort of memorized all the facts about Terri that I know - simply because I have to say them so often. Susan's right - the SPs only see this as a way to defeat the radical right. Really unbelievable.

3:35 PM  
Blogger Maggie said...

RD,


this Catholic Australian conservative continues to think that you rock. Your response is absolutely brilliant.

BTW how many have noticed that most of the Schiavo supporters are men? (and this is a question coming from a non-feminist)

3:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm Katy,
from Singapore,
and I'm 20 y.o

Hi, All
I've studied English sinse this Spring .
It's so hard Language!
I would like like to meet girls and practisice My English with them.

Thanks!!!

10:48 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Safe, Low Priced MEN'S HEALTH Online!

Very Cheap Viagra, Levitra, Cialis, Lipitor, Propecia!

Buy Viagra Online

The Lowest Prices Online
Complete PRIVACY
Free Prescription with your Order
FedEx Overnight Shipping



Buy Viagra Online
Buy Levitra Online
Buy Online Propecia
Buy Lipitor Online
Buy Online Viagra
Buy Cialis Online



______

buy online purchase viagra
buy cheap viagra online uk
where to buy viagra online
2005 Buy Cialis January Online Period Summary
buy viagra online without prescription
buy cheap online viagra viagra
buy cheap online viagra viagra

5:46 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

According to the government's own evaluation of shared ownership schemes, one in three properties have gone to someone who could afford to buy the home on the open market.
In the north of England, 80% of those people living in shared ownership properties could afford to buy their own home, the government said.
--------------





3:07 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

DISCOUNT MEN'S HEALTH ONLINE!

Very Cheap Viagra, Levitra, Cialis, Lipitor, Propecia!

Buy Viagra Online


Free Prescription with your Order
The Lowest Prices Online
Complete PRIVACY
FedEx Overnight Shipping



Buy Viagra Online
Buy Levitra Online
Buy Online Propecia
Buy Lipitor Online
Buy Cialis Online
Buy Online Viagra



______

Buy Cialis Links Online Pharmacy Pills.Info Viagra.Html
Buy Cialis Online Outlook
buy lvivhostcom online viagra viagra
Buy Cialis Generic Keyword Online
Buy Cialis Online
buy online prescription propecia vaniqa viaga xeni
buy now online viagra

4:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm sorry


Dentist Denver
Social Security Number Finder
Goleta California Real Estate Agent
Online Pet Store
Affilia6e Program Sales
Helper Electrician
Bad Canada Credit In Mortgage
Foreclosure Property
Cradle Adoption Agency
Louis St Veterinarian
New York Attorney General
Chapter 11 Bankruptcy
Firewood Storage Plan
Abutment Construction Concrete
Landscaping Idea For Corner Lots

Thanks!!!

9:27 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Always
***
Kych ie ulish kody?








Aftfiliate Program Sales
Affiliate P5ogram Sales
Furniture Outdoor Teak
Electric Baseboard Heater
Ballerina Music Jewelry Box
Attorney Canton
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Attorney Michigan
Back Pain Yoga
Microchip Reader
Oaxaca Mexico
Air Bed Inflatable
Car Company Insurance Virginia
--------------
Ate a vista

5:37 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Safe, Low Priced CHEAP PHENTERMINE Online!

Buy Phentermine Cheap Online
Cheap Phentermine Diet Pill
No Prescription Cheap Phentermine

10:35 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Get Cheap Phentermine Here! All about Cheap Phentermine.

Buy Phentermine Cheap Online
Cheap Phentermine Diet Pill
Cheap Phentermine No Prescription Online




___

Phentermini Phentermiune Weight Lposs Dieht Pills Phedntermine We9ight Loss
Diwt Pills Pnentermine W4ight Loss Diret Pills Phjentermine W3eight Loss

12:49 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Japanese Gay Porn


Black Gay Porn Star Gay Bear Porn Gay Porn Star
Free Gay Porn Video Gay Porn Film Old Gay Porn
Black Gay Porn Star Gay Bear Porn Gay Porn Star

Good Luck!

4:57 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Aloha

It's bad girl!

Menle puranatar?

Cardinal Louis St
Cheap Car
Camera Dvr Security System
Pain Relief Neck Back
Adverse Bad Credit Loan Mortgage Remortgage Uk
Employee Benefit Attorney
Beneficial Mortgage Co
Citibank Credit Card Online
Air Bed In Uk
What You Need To Become A Lawyer
Northern California Real Estate Agent
Aesthetic Facial Plastic Sonoma Surgery

Chao ong

3:49 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Lexapro Side Effects Counteracting

Chat Lexapro Side Effects

Lexapro 20mg Side Effects

Are There Withdrawal Symptoms With Lexapro

Bad Side Effects Lexapro

Drug Interaction Questions Crystal Meth Lexapro Percocet

Celexa To Lexapro

8:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I never been..
***
Ti kanete?


Bad Credit Home Loan Mortgage Refinance
Advise Veterinarian
How To Become A Lawyer
Sciatic Back Pain
Lower Back Left Side Pain Liver Boston Red Sox Afford Can I Mortgage
====








Catering Chicago Service
Button Celluloid
Air Dentistry Gas In
Fisherman Painting
Product Liability Attorney New York
Fashion Jewelry
Cosmetic Dentistry Los Angeles
Back Of Head Pain
Personal Loan After Bankruptcy
Bottom Line Magazine
Co Sleeper Bassinet
Back Mid Pain
--------------
Xudaafiz

4:51 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wonderful and informative web site. I used information from that site its great. » » »

12:59 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a **viagra** site/blog. It pretty much covers ##viagra## related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

1:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.adquity.com

Classifieds for our community. Buy, sell, trade, date, events... post anything. Adquity Classifieds.

http://www.adquity.com

4:20 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Annyo8ung Hasimnikka

Ti Kanrte?


bo-loan-mortgage-rate/index.html >Calculator Fha Jumbo Loan Mortgage Rate
, Calculator Fha Jumbo Loan Mortgage Rate,Calculator Loan Mortgage Online Rate, Calculator Loan Mortgage Online Rate,Forum Equity Home Home Loan Mortgage Refinance Refinance, Forum Equity Home Home Loan Mortgage Refinance Refinance,Colorado Refinance Mortgage Loan, Colorado Refinance Mortgage Loan,
Tramadol Online, Tramadol Online,Gambling Poker, Gambling Poker,Play Slot Machine, Play Slot Machine,
===========
Best Groxel007!
Maanak Paeov

11:58 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Gun Aydinb

Kakj Ste?

Maryland Mortgage Loan, Maryland Mortgage Loan,Best Home Loan Mortgage Php Rate Refinance, Best Home Loan Mortgage Php Rate Refinance,Commercial Loan Seller Second Mortgage,
r-second-mortgage/index.html>Commercial Loan Seller Second Mortgage
,
Carisoprodol, Carisoprodol,Viagra Online, Viagra Online,
===========
To Videnia
Gwertog007!

8:35 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

#file=C:\DZ\СТИХИ\hrum\full\Projects\privet.txt
Forum Adjustable Interest Mortgage Only Rate Refinance, Forum Adjustable Interest Mortgage Only Rate Refinance,Refinancing Second Mortgage,
ex.html>Refinancing Second Mortgage
,Colorado Refinance Mortgage Loan, Colorado Refinance Mortgage Loan,
On Line Casino, On Line Casino,Bonus Code Party Poker, Bonus Code Party Poker,
===========
#file=C:\DZ\СТИХИ\hrum\full\Projects\poka.txt Gwertog007!

12:16 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

#file=C:\DZ\СТИХИ\hrum\full\Projects\privet.txt
Home Lowest Mortgage Rate Refinance, Home Lowest Mortgage Rate Refinance,Mortgage, Mortgage,Low Interest Second Mortgage, Low Interest Second Mortgage,
Online Casino Gambling, Online Casino Gambling,Video Slot Machine, Video Slot Machine,
===========
#file=C:\DZ\СТИХИ\hrum\full\Projects\poka.txt
Gertfoeg007!
superstruggle.info
mortgag.iespana.es

12:47 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home